Home » Our Work » Accountability » Prosecutors Holding Prosecutors Accountable for Illegal Practices in Orleans Parish

Holding Prosecutors Accountable for Illegal Practices in Orleans Parish

Singleton et al. v. Cannizzaro et al.

Our lawsuit sought to end the unconstitutional deception and jailing of crime victims and witnesses by the Orleans Parish District Attorney’s Office. The lawsuit accused District Attorney Leon Cannizzaro’s office of fabricating subpoenas to coerce crime victims and witnesses of crimes into submitting to private out-of-court interrogations; illegal attempts to coerce untruthful testimony; and office-wide practice of presenting fraudulent information in court to persuade judges to issue arrest warrants. In 2017, Civil Rights Corps, with our partners at the ACLU and the ACLU of Louisiana, filed a lawsuit in federal court against District Attorney Cannizzaro and ten assistant district attorneys.

In a landmark opinion, the Fifth Circuit denied the prosecutors’ request for absolute immunity at the motion to dismiss stage. In 2021, ultimately, the case resulted in a settlement requiring defendants to end the illegal practices, make significant policy changes to minimize the use of material witness warrants and incarceration of witnesses, pay monetary damages, and cooperate with an independent, court-appointed monitor to oversee the use of material witness warrants and treatment of witnesses.


Media Coverage:

Settlement ends lawsuit over fake subpoenas, jailed victims | Associated Press | Oct 5, 2021
Federal judges scathing on fake subpoenas in New Orleans, but don't rule on key question | nola.com | Feb 5, 2020
Judges deliberating in Orleans DA fake subpoena appeal | WDSU6 News | Feb 6, 2020
Why Are Prosecutors Putting Innocent Witnesses in Jail? | The New Yorker | Oct 17, 2017
New Orleans Prosecutors Accused of Using Fake Subpoenas | New York Time | Oct 17, 2017
Lawsuit: Orleans prosecutors violated people’s civil rights with systemic use of fake subpoenas | The Lens | Oct 17, 2017
Suit Against DA who used fake subpoenas to put victims in jail kicks off civil rights battle | Huffington Post | Oct 17, 2017


Partners:

ACLU
ACLU of Louisiana


Filings:

Settlement Agreement (Oct 15, 2021)
Opinion: 5th Circuit Court of Appeals (Apr 21, 2020)
Memo in Opposition to Motion for Summary Judgment (Dec 15, 2020)
Ruling on Motion to Dismiss (Feb 28, 2019)
Opposition to Motion to Dismiss (Apr 5, 2018)
Second Amended Complaint (Jan 25, 2018)