Orleans Parish, LA: Bail

In 2017, Civil Rights Corps filed a landmark federal class action lawsuit challenging the unconstitutional money bail system in New Orleans, Louisiana. Each of our clients was confined in the notorious Orleans Parish Prison because he could not afford to pay a money bond after his arrest. In Louisiana, the judges who set money bonds, the prosecutors who ask for them, the sheriffs who enforce them, and the public defenders who represent the human beings who suffer from them each take a percentage cut of every money bond paid. Thousands of other people are currently going through what our named Plaintiffs went through.

In August 2018, we won summary judgment in this case. In a landmark opinion, the court essentially held that New Orleans' money-bail system violates equal protection and due process. The court also struck down Louisiana's statewide statutory scheme that gives judges an institutional financial conflict of interest when setting money bail.

For months following summary judgement, local courts blatantly violated the decree, routinely setting money bail amounts that people could not afford. In June 2019, the federal court issued a historic injunction that requires the elected judge in charge of money bail to follow a specific protocol when making decisions about pretrial release and detention. If the judge does not follow the protocol, they can be held in contempt of the federal court.

In August 2019, the 5th circuit court of appeals ruled unanimously that the Louisiana bail system—where judges take a percentage cut of every monetary bond they set to fund their courts—is unconstitutional. We are working through all of the implications and enforcement options, but the ruling basically means that under current Louisiana law, judges are not permitted to set monetary bonds.

This case will go a long way towards ending wealth-based detention and the unconstitutional financial conflict of interest that pervades the Louisiana criminal system.

 

Partners: MacArthur Justice Center

 

Filings:

Complaint
Summary Judgment Opinion
Injunction Order
Opinion: 5th Circuit Court of Appeals

 

Media Coverage:

US appeals court: Another conflict in New Orleans courts
Appeals court ruling could bolster case against New Orleans bail system
Federal lawsuit targets bond practices of Orleans Magistrate Judge Harry Cantrell, Jr.
America Is Waking Up to the Injustice of Cash Bail
New Orleans judges enter 'uncharted territory,' and budget peril, after federal court decisions